2/7/16: Firehouse Bagels

Hi Everyone!

On Super Bowl Sunday, we visited Firehouse Bagels in Holtsville!

Firehouse Bagels
1018 Waverly Ave
Holtsville, NY 11742
Phone: 631-569-4693

Bryan ordered a very well-toasted sesame bagel with just a little bit of cream cheese.  Rebecca ordered a light-colored sesame bagel with cream cheese.  Here's how we rated it:

Taste: 3
Atmosphere: 2 1/2
Service: 4
Cost: $4.89

We enjoyed our bagels, though we agree they weren't the best we've ever had.  Bryan definitely enjoyed his more than Rebecca liked hers.  The store was very small, with very little seating and an extremely small waiting area.  We were impressed with the service we received.  Our server made sure that our bagels turned out just the way we had ordered them.

Overall, we would give this bagel place an "average" rating.

Don't forget to check us out next week when we head somewhere new!

Bryan and Rebecca

1/31/16: Bagels Your Way Cafe--College Plaza

Hi Everyone!

As you might imagine, we didn't visit any new bagel places last week because of the major snowstorm that hit LI!  Yesterday, though, we were back on the road!  We visited Bagels Your Way Cafe in College Plaza, Selden!

Bagels Your Way Cafe
89 College Plaza
Selden, NY 11784
631-732-2050
www.bagelsyourwaycafe.com
bagelsyourwaycafe@gmail.com

Rebecca ordered a light-colored sesame bagel with cream cheese.  Bryan ordered a well-toasted sesame bagel with just a little bit of cream cheese.  Here's how we rated it:

Taste: 3
Atmosphere: 3.5
Service: 4.5
Cost: $4.50

We thought our bagels were average; they weren't the best we've had, but they still tasted pretty good.  Also of note is the fact that the bagels are comparatively small.  The store was nice, if not a little cramped due to its small size.  We were very satisfied with the service we received.  Our server made sure Rebecca's bagel was light and that Bryan's bagel was well toasted with just a little cream cheese.  They truly do make their bagels "your way"!

Overall, we were satisfied with our experience at Bagels Your Way Cafe, but wouldn't rank it among our top picks.

Don't forget to check us out next week when we head somewhere new!

Bryan and Rebecca